The Social and Economic implications of the cotter class in the West highlands and Islands, c. 1790-1900
My Carnegie Trust vacation Scholarship: A Blog by Mark Mclaughlan.
My name is Mark Mclaughlan and I am a third year undergraduate student, reading History at the University of Dundee. The purpose of this blog is to chart my progress through the Carnegie Trust Vacation Scholarship project. The focus of this project is to examine the cottar or landless class in the Scottish Highlands in the 19th century, with a specific attention to be paid to the islands of Tiree and Coll, situated in the Inner Hebrides on the west coast of Scotland, Which is part of the Argyll Estate.
This proved to be an interesting proposition from the start, especially as studying the Scottish Highlands through the course of my degree, it became obvious that through time the cottars have not figured much in current historiography. With this in mind it seemed obvious to me that this was an area that required some attention, and when I was informed by my tutor that the Carnegie Trust awarded vacation scholarships to undergraduate students, it seemed like to good an opportunity to pass up on. So after applying and successfully being awarded the scholarship I find myself writing this blog.
So just how will I approach this large and rather daunting task? The following objectives should make the answer to that question a little clearer.
- How and why was the cottar class established in the Highlands and islands, with a specific case study focus on the Argyll estates?
- What effect did the cottar class in the early nineteenth century have socially and culturally on the islands of Tiree and Coll?
- In the harsh economic environment in the west highlands and islands in the 19th century what effect did the support of the cottar class have on the Argyll estate management?
- What economic issues did the cottars provide for the Argyll estate management through the periods of highland improvement?
By examining these questions I hope to present a clearer picture if the cottar class who undoubtedly represented a large percentage of the population of Tiree and Coll. This will be achieved by conducting archival based research at the National Archive of Scotland and the National Library of Scotland in Edinburgh, and by consulting the Argyll Papers situated in the archive at Inveraray castle on the Argyll Estate, and desktop research at the University of Dundee. Throughout the period of the six weeks of the project I will update this blog on a regular basis, an include Photos of my travels and interesting documents. More importantly as I progress through the project this will provide an outlet for my thoughts and ideas during the information gathering and analysis process, which I’m sure will uncover a number of interesting results.
I will therefore end this first blog entry by expressing thanks to the Carnegie Trust for presenting me with this fantastic opportunity, and also my supervisor who continues to provide advice and support that I am sure will be ever more required as the week’s progress.
Sounds absolutely fascinating and I look forward to hearing more – good luck with it. Can we sign up for updates?
Hi Mark,
Sounds brilliant. Send me an email or FB message me some time. I’m specifically interested in the same topic and time period. My family was a cottar family on Tiree from at least 1779-1881. Some of the family made the transition to crofter, but my great great grandfather never did, and migrated to Glasgow in the late 19th century.
Archie Henderson
https://m.facebook.com/ArchieHendersonHistoricalResearch/
Delighted to read this blog Mark. We look forward to following your project.
It sounds like your approach is centred primarily on the estate’s conceptualisation of and management of this class of people. Yet question number 2 allows for asking about wider issues, perceptions, conceptualisations and relationships of, with and between members of Gaelic society internally.
What Gaelic sources will you be utilising for this? The fortunate thing is that there is an abundance of them for 19th-century Tiree, even just in the single collection Na Baird Thirisdeach there are dozens. Plus of course there are loads of recordings in Tobar an Dualchais.
Excellent – a huge gap in the historiography. I look forward to hearing what you can find out from the sources which you can access.
Recent Blog Posts
Celebration of the 1919 Land Settlement (Scotland) Act August 19, 2019
The Northern Scotland and Centre for Scotland’s Land Futures Essay Prize 2018 May 30, 2018
Upcoming Seminar: Dr Allan Kennedy, ‘Civility, Order and the Highlands in Cromwellian Britain’ February 5, 2018
Frank Rennie on the Highlands, Rural Development and Remoteness September 27, 2017
New Centre for Scotland’s Land Futures Blog September 20, 2017
Type of post
Blog Calendar
Contact us – Stirling
Centre for Environment, Heritage & Policy
University of Stirling
Stirling FK9 4LA
01786 466250
g.f.m.little@stir.ac.uk
Contact Us – Dundee
University of Dundee
Dundee DD1 4HN
01382 384536
h.yeung@dundee.ac.uk
Contact Us – Highlands and Islands
University of Highlands and Islands
Burghfield House
Cnoc-an-Lobht
Dornoch IV25 3HN
01847 889628
iain.robertson@uhi.ac.uk